Skip to main content

The Question I Used to Hate (But Don't Anymore)

How many Bible studies have you attended in your life? I can say that I've attended my fair share, both as teacher and as participant. There are few things in life that I love more than gathering together with a group and working through Scripture together. In particular I love it when there is a good, robust discussion about God or Christ or something that challenges us.

Having primarily been the discussion leader the past several years, I can tell you that it can be tricky to come up with good questions that stimulate conversation. It's something that I've gotten significantly better at over the years, but it can still be a challenge. There is one question that I hear a lot of teachers or discussion leaders ask that for a long time I used to absolutely hate. 

"What does this verse/passage mean to you?"

My dislike of this question began while studying Bible at Harding. I was learning all about context, hermeneutical methods, and exegesis. We had it drilled into our heads that any given text had to mean what the original author meant it to mean. In other words, there was an objective meaning to every part of the Bible and our job was to, through careful study, discover it.

After only a few weeks at Harding I was attending a Bible study and the leader asked this question after reading a passage from the Sermon on the Mount (I don't remember what exactly). People in the group started explaining how what Jesus had said made them feel, and the responses ranged from comfort to anger to confusion to one guy rambling about some very specific issue that no one else cared about. I, having now been enlightened to the way of true Bible scholarship, was quietly seething. Who cares what you felt the passage meant? What matters is what Jesus meant!

I'm slightly ashamed to say that I stopped going to that Bible study after that because that question was asked. My fellow Bible majors and I would often discuss with distaste how other people just didn't get it. After all, the Bible was too important a thing to be left to the personal feelings and whims of individuals. True interpretation needed to be done by those that understood context and the original languages.

I carried this animosity for this simple question for years after that. I was always very careful not to ask this question if I was ever leading a Bible study or teaching a class because I thought it was counter-productive. I attempted to ask questions that got people thinking about the context of the passage rather than what they felt about it. 

As the title of this post indicates, I no longer hate this question. In fact, I actually now think that it is a very important question to ask. I've realized that the real problem was not with the question itself, but rather with the lack of follow up and shepherding that should have accompanied it.

We need to be honest about how we, as individuals, read and hear things through our own biases and personalities. Asking "What does this verse/passage mean to you?" is actually a simple way to begin to unveil those things. The very fact that this question can elicit, on the same passage of Scripture, so many different answers shows us that our unique biases and thought processes play a much larger role in Bible study than we often acknowledge.

The important piece that is so often missing with this question is the follow up. Too often we ask this question, let everyone answer, and then move onto the next passage. What needs to happen is engagement with these different answers with the context and research about what the author intended. We shouldn't just move on without engaging people's answers just as we shouldn't avoid the question in the first place by focusing solely on exegesis and research. 

When we fail to engage and follow up on those answers and just move on instead, it places our individual interpretations and feelings become the primary authority on what Scripture says. When we skip the question entirely we don't address the biases and filters people have that can dramatically affect the way they read Scripture. What we need to do is both things. We need to be willing to engage people's preconceptions and gut feelings about passages head on with the research and context that points to the original intent.

So please do ask "What does this verse/passage mean to you?" Just don't forget to engage people where they are at. Ask follow up questions. Bring up context gently and with the intent of helping others grow and not as a hammer to wreck others with. Remember that the process of studying Scripture is a two way street. It is the intersection of what God is saying through the authors and how we read it now. The goal is not to eliminate one side or the other, but rather to conform how we read it now to what God is saying.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

We Need More Images

What is your favorite way to describe God? Is there a particular name of God in scripture that you are drawn to? What images and pictures come to mind when you think of God? These are questions I don't think we ask often enough. We all have an image of God in our heads that we work with. It may not be a literal picture, though it might be, but ideas and concepts we tend to associate with who God is. Some of those images and associations may come from the Bible, but some may not. These things are influenced by our upbringing, Bible reading habits, personalities, relationships, culture, and more. The way we picture God has a dramatic impact on the way we live our lives. For example, if the primary idea you have of God is "Healer," when you hear or read that you are made in God's image you will likely feel called to heal, be it physical ailments or spiritual wounds. But, if your primary image of God is "Judge," that changes things. You very likely might tend to...

Thankful

Today is Thanksgiving, the day that we are supposed to celebrate all the things we are thankful for. It is a time of family reunions, football, and turkey eating. I sincerely pray that each and every one of you has a good day today. I'll admit that being thankful has not been easy for me this year. As pretty much all of you know, my mother passed away December of last year. Though she had been in the hospital for months, we were not expecting it. In fact I was sure she would be finally able to come home within a matter of weeks. Instead she peacefully passed on into the arms of Jesus, whom she loved more dearly than anyone else. As you can imagine, the entire family was heart broken. After what can easily be described as the worst Christmas ever, I returned to home to Illinois. It was here that I finally broke down. I spent the next months doing everything except being thankful. I cursed God, wept, screamed, begged to have her back, and was generally not the nicest person to be...

The Early Middle Ages: Historical Friday

The next segment of history that we are going to overview is the Early Middle Ages. This dates roughly from AD 450 to AD 1100. This is intended to be a very general overview. There are probably historians that would classify some other time period as the "Early Middle Ages" or a more specific time period. For our purposes this will cover the aforementioned time period. This was a very influential period in the history of Christianity. It saw the formation of what we now call the Roman Catholic Church and its separation from what we would now call the Eastern Orthodox Church. Before this time there was only ONE church. There weren't different denominations or groups. It is hard for us to think about in our modern context, but there was a time when Christianity was visibly unified. Brief History The first major thing to happen during this time period is the remaining three ecumenical councils. We discussed the first four several weeks ago. These councils discussed va...